Not Just Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Not Just Pizza in Brooklyn serves up a delightful array of options for pizza lovers. The menu features 19 varieties of pizzas, from classic cheese slices to generous extra-large pies. Each slice delivers authentic flavors, and you can grab a large pie for a gathering or a medium for a quick meal. The gyro is a crowd favorite, packed with flavors that complement the pizza well. Wash it all down with a refreshing selection of drinks, including canned sodas and San Pellegrino. With an average price around $8.89, enjoying a meal here won’t break the bank.

Not Just Pizza Menu image 1
Not Just Pizza Menu image 2
Not Just Pizza Menu image 3

Featured Dishes

Slice Pizza
Slice Pizza
Not Just Pizza

Not Just Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Step into Not Just Pizza, and you're welcomed by a warm and casual atmosphere. The decor features a mix of modern and traditional elements, creating a cozy dining space. The open layout enables a glimpse into the kitchen, where the magic happens. The inviting aroma of baking pizza fills the air, enhancing the dining experience. Tables are often filled with cheerful groups enjoying their meals, reflecting the community vibe of Brooklyn. Overall, it offers a friendly place to relish pizza and share good times.

Not Just Pizza

About Not Just Pizza Food and Specialties

Not Just Pizza stands out for its simple yet satisfying food offerings. Customers rave about the cheese pizza, noting that it’s perfectly baked with a crispy crust and generous cheese that stretches with every bite. Gyros add variety to the menu, featuring tender meat wrapped in warm pita. Besides pizza and gyros, the sweet allure of freshly baked cookies draws in patrons looking for a comforting treat. The restaurant caters to different appetites, making it ideal for both a quick lunch and a cozy dinner with friends.

Not Just Pizza

Not Just Pizza prides itself on a simple yet powerful commitment — to serve delicious food at affordable prices. This restaurant focuses on offering quality ingredients, ensuring each dish tastes as good as it looks. The menu highlights specialty pizzas that cater to varied tastes, with the cheese pizza frequently noted for its perfect melt and crust.

The vision of Not Just Pizza extends beyond delicious food. It aims to build a community around great dining experiences. The focus is on ensuring everyone feels at home, whether dining in or taking out. Building relationships with regular customers helps create a sense of belonging, making it much more than just a pizza joint.